“An Open Letter to Mayor Sam Sullivan and City Council From Women in the Downtown Eastside (July 2, 2007)”
For poor/middle-class people, especially poor (though one is supposed to use the sanitized term ‘low income cut-off’) people - the elderly, people on social assistance, disability pensions, the on-going development in Vancouver area as well as other areas of BC is making life unbearable.
This open letter is to challenge Mayor Sam Sullivan,
Councillor Suzanne
Anton, Councillor Elizabeth Ball, Councillor David Cadman,
Councillor Kim
Capri, Councillor George Chow, Councillor Heather Deal,
Councillor Peter
Ladner, Councillor B.C. Lee, Councillor Raymond Louie, and
Councillor Tim
Stevenson to a House Swap with women of the Power of Women
Group.
The Power of Women Group a group at the Downtown Eastside
Women’s Centre
and we are dedicated to educating and raising awareness on
social issues.
We are a group of women from all walks of life who are
either on social
assistance, working poor, or homeless; but we are all
living in extreme
poverty below the poverty line. Many us of are single
mothers or have had
our children apprehended due to poverty; most of us have
chronic physical
or mental health issues for example HIV and Hepatitis C;
many have drug or
alcohol addictions; and a majority have experienced and
survived sexual
violence and mental, physical, spiritual , and emotional
abuse. For
indigenous women, we are affected by a multi generational
legacy of the
effects of residential schools and a history of
colonization and racism.
We believe that politicians far too frequently make
declarations and
decisions about ‘resolving’ poverty particularly in the
Downtown Eastside
(DTES) without having any idea about the painful reality of
those who live
in the DTES. All the overwhelming and well-documented
research and
statistics about growing poverty especially for single
mothers, the
‘housing crisis’, violence against women particularly
Indigenous women,
the effects of the Olympics, and the inadequacy of social
assistance rates
seem to have little impact on policy-makers. Therefore,
instead of
offering any new evidence or research or even our own
voices and stories,
we challenge you to walk in our shoes, even for a brief
amount of time and
for a fraction of the distance.
Our conditions for the House Swap challenge, that we
believe are far less
onerous than our struggle which is a daily struggle and not
time-limited,
are as follows:
- The House Swap will be for a minimum of eight weeks.
- Each council member lives off only $610 per month- the
basic support and
shelter payment amount for a single person on social
assistance. Excluding
shelter amounts, this averages to under $8 per day.
- There shall be no external financial support (including
use of credit
cards or any other gift, credit, or loan of money) nor will
Council
members have access to any private vehicles.
- The only external material support will be limited to
clothes and food,
if needed, and provided by DTES-serving agencies as per
their regular
donations policies.
- No media reporting of any kind.
- Each council member brings the following to the House
Swap: basic
necessities, no more than two appliances (such as TV and
stereo), and at
least ten items of personal sentimental value.
- We believe it will be much easier for you to rent a room
in an SRO hotel
for the whole duration as you will not experience the
discrimination that
we do when attempting to rent, therefore at least two weeks
of the eight
weeks must be spent homeless.
- All Council work, including Council meetings, is
conducted in the DTES.
We are happy to setup meeting rooms for this.
- Daily check-in with the Power of Women Group who will
ensure no
conditions are being violated.
During the House Swap, we will live in the lap of luxury as
you do; while
you will experience some of the following (we believe you
will be able to
avoid many of them):
* Homelessness including sleeping in doorways, alleys,
shelter beds, park
benches; having to carry as many belongings as you can with
but chances
are that they will all be stolen including your wheelchair,
your last pair
of clean clothes, and your items of sentimental value. If
you are able to
access a shelter, you will have to leave by early in the
morning, ensure
you are in by curfew time, and you may not be able to bring
in a cart that
has all your belongings.
* Highly regulated schedule in order to ensure various
appointments with
health care workers, Ministry of Employment and Income
Assistance workers,
advocacy appointments, scheduled meals, getting in line
early for a
shelter bed, arriving early to get clothing donations
before it runs out,
and being able to access general services based on hours of
operation of
agencies.
* Living in a Single Room Occupancy hotel room that is
infested with bed
bugs, rodents, and cockroaches. Your entire room will be
the size of a
closet with no bathroom or kitchen in the room and there
will likely be
structural problems with the building that will result in
leaks through
your roof and accumulation of mould in the room. The
landlord may keep
your damage deposit after you leave; illegally enforce
guest fees; deny
you essential services such as heat, running water, and
elevator services
for those with disabilities; cooperate with police in
illegal searches;
illegally enter your premises without notice; and illegally
evict you. *
Going hungry, standing in a food bank line for 1 hour,
eating rotting or
rotten food from a dumpster.
* Infrequent and irregular access to a bathroom therefore
having to
defacate and urinate in the streets at times.
* Police violence including being woken up from doorways
with multiple
kicks; illegal search and seizures; police entry into your
premises
without warrants; and general heightened police
surveillance.
* General and overwhelming sense of social isolation while
living with a
complete lack of privacy, stigma, fear, disempowerment,
anger,
frustration, chronic depression, grief, and desire for
radical social change.
What you will experience in this House Swap Challenge will
not come close
to the totality of our experiences; for example the history
of violence
and abuse that has brought many of us women here; the
addictions that
break our souls; the brutality of child apprehension many
of us have borne
as a direct result of poverty; that many of us do not know
our parents
because the legacy of residential schools and colonization
has destroyed
our entire family; the chronic and often fatal illnesses
such as AIDS and
Hepatitis C that have made us weak; the grief of living
through the deaths
of our missing and murdered sisters; and much more. We have
survived these
brutal realities and they have made us stronger.
Are you strong enough to bear a small percentage of our
reality? If you
refuse to participate in our House Swap Challenge, or find
some excuse for
why it is impossible or not feasible, then it will confirm
for us what
many already believe: that there is absolutely no
political will to
eliminate poverty; instead government policies and social
apathy will
continue to create and perpetuate the violence of poverty
and
displacement.
To all those who believe that this is a fair challenge, we
strongly
encourage you to please contact City Council at
mayorandcouncil@vancouver.ca or call at 604-873-7621 and
tell them you
support our House Swap Challenge and tell them to
participate.
To contact us, please do so via Harsha Walia, Project
Coordinator at the
Downtown Eastside Women’s Centre at 604-681-8480 x 234 or
through email at
project@dewc.ca.
Signed,
Members of the Power of Women Group
Downtown Eastside Women’s Centre
302 Columbia Street, Vancouver, BC, V6A 4J1
Email: project@dewc.ca
Tel: (604) 681-8480 x234
Fax: (604) 681-8470
